Panchamahabhuta — the five great elements Facebook  ·  X  ·  Write to me →

If you want one honest answer to what traditional medicine has given the world, it is this list. Each of these began as a plant used by people with no chemistry at all, and each is now a medicine that saves lives.

What the list actually shows

It shows that traditional knowledge is a serious source of leads. Old texts and old practitioners pointed to plants that laboratories would never have chosen at random, and the hit rate was far better than chance.

It also shows what had to be added. In every case the plant was variable and often unsafe; the achievement was isolating the compound, working out the dose, and testing it. Withering spent a decade on foxglove dosing precisely because foxglove kills people at slightly too much. The tradition supplied the lead. The method supplied the medicine.

That is why I think the argument between traditional and modern medicine is mostly a false one. They did different jobs, and the results we have came from both.

The other side of the list

The same traditions also produced remedies that killed: mercury for syphilis, bloodletting for almost everything, arsenic tonics, aristolochia. Plants are not safe because they are natural — foxglove, aconite, datura and oleander are all traditional medicines and all lethal at modest doses.

Please do not self-medicate with plant preparations you have read about.

Please read this first

This site is a personal account and a record of traditional practice, shared for information. It is not medical advice, not a diagnosis, and not a treatment for any disease. I am not a doctor.

If you are unwell — and especially if you have a serious illness such as cancer, diabetes or heart disease — please stay under the care of a qualified physician. Nothing here should replace or delay that care.

More in this section